Several years ago, a seemingly insignificant incident happened in my life that started a thought process that weighs on my heart to this day. After reading a Facebook post this week, I feel the need to try to articulate this to anyone in the fetish world who is willing to listen. I am trying hard to not sound accusatory or judgmental (as I feel these are two huge downfalls in the gay community), but rather I am trying to share my passion.
About 6 years ago, I had gone out for the evening to a leather bar. I was wearing a pair of chaps, a jock, and a black novelty t-shirt that said “Good boys need spanking too.” Since I typically carried a paddle or a flogger, I thought the shirt was appropriate. That night, however, I did not have any gear with me, nor was I flagging anything. While there, a man came up from behind me and smacked me in the ass. He smacked me hard, and it was a complete surprise. It actually left a bruise. I’ll be honest, my initial instinct was to turn around and beat the hell out of him. However, I collected myself, put myself back into my surroundings and addressed him. The conversation went something like this:
Me, “Why did you just hit me?”
Him, “Your shirt says you want it.”
Me, “My shirt has a phrase on it. How does that mean that I want YOU to do anything?”
Him, “You have a bare ass. If you don’t want it smacked, you shouldn’t be showing it.”
Me, “You have a bare face, so does that mean that you want me to slug you?”
Him, “If you do, I will knock you out.”
Me, “Well, if fair is fair, bend over…because I’m gonna give you the paddling of a lifetime.”
Him, “I’m a Domme, I don’t do that.”
Me, “In order to be a Domme, you have to have permission to put someone into submission.”
Him, “I don’t need permission from anyone.”
Me, “Then you don’t know what it means to be a Leatherman, OR a Domme.”
At this point, it got very ugly. We argued about permission, respect, and submission. After a very heated discussion, an astute bartender separated us….
I went home very angry. I wasn’t angry because he had hit me. I was angry because he truly felt that he had the right to do so, just because he had proclaimed himself as dominant.
The things that originally drew me to the leather community had nothing to do with attire; they had to do with respect. As foreign as the concepts of BDSM were to me, I was drawn by the level of trust and respect that I saw. The leather was just a bonus. I was drawn by the concept that someone could have such deep appreciation for someone that they would be willing to put themselves under submission of the other person. Although I have always had a bit of a dominant streak in me, I had never seen it displayed the way that it is displayed in the leather community. It was a depth of relationship that I had never seen before. It’s a beautifully symbiotic relationship…most of the time.
Since then, I have moved on into different levels of the leather community. I learned from a very gentle, patient man. He recognized that I was not built to be a “forever” boy. Rather, he groomed me to draw from within myself the kind of Sir that I would be. Several hit-and-miss relationships later, I found myself with a leather pup. It was the niche that I had been missing. Playful boys and/or pups were unquestionably what I had been looking for. Although I am in the dominant role, I find that I am probably more passive about my requirements, rather than demanding. To my mind, a different style with the same results. Perhaps ONLY to my mind….
About two years ago, I was out with my pup at a leather bar that was having a bondage night. It was a typical leather bar night, but amped-up a bit. The pup and I were having a good time. We had warmed up and were moving progressively higher…with a long way to go. Out of the blue, something unexpected happened. I suspect that this has happened to many leathermen in play sessions. My hand was not as steady as I expected…he moved in a direction that I didn’t anticipate…I’m not exactly sure how it happened…but I hurt him. I knew INSTANTLY. It was not a question of him having to yelp, or whimper, or use our safe word. I could tell by the look in his eye that I had hurt him. I stopped immediately, grabbed him around the neck and pulled him close to me. I asked if he was ok. I apologized. …and my eyes welled up with tears.
Later, I was chastised by a few of the local leathermen for this. I was ridiculed, publically, for not being a very manly “Sir.” Truthfully, I distanced myself from the local leather community for a couple of years because it.
You see, my concept of dominant and submissive is very different. I’m not in a dominant role because it makes me manly, or because I’m a top, or because I have a narcissistic need to be in control. I’m in a dominant role because that is how my love expresses itself. When someone submits to me, it doesn’t make me want to lord my dominance over them. Rather, it is a new responsibility to me; A responsibility that was freely given to me. This person is now completely trusting me to treat them right. This person is now depending on me to take control, but continue to keep their safety and best interests ahead of my own. This person has trusted me to protect them and care for them. They have trusted me in a way that I struggle to trust others. I take that as a promise…a commitment…and I take it seriously. I take it far too seriously to make it all about ‘me.’
Granted, each relationship that we enter is different, and every person that we play with has different thresholds of physical pain and/or emotional humiliation. So, I am in no way trying to judge any one person or any one relationship, because I have no way to externally know what their relationship is about. I’m just asking us all to look closely at those who submit to us to make sure that we, first and foremost, have their best interests at heart. Without it, I personally think that we have lost the most important part of the relationship: respect. And, unlike submission, respect can never be forced, it can only be given.